Warning: Beefy spoilers put together for Dim Widow.
One of many highlights of the Dim Widow film is David Harbour’s Red Guardian, a.good ample.a. Alexei Shostakov, the faded deep-duvet Russian perceive who change into once additionally at one point that nation’s acknowledge to Captain The United States. While the main arc of his persona is basically based entirely mostly spherical his relationship alongside with his adopted household of fellow faded and/or most up-to-the-minute Russian brokers Natasha Romanoff (Scarlett Johansson), Yelena Belova (Florence Pugh), and Melina Vostokoff (Rachel Weisz), a working funny legend within the film involves Alexei recalling his glory days, and namely his self-proclaimed rivalry with Captain The United States.
Nonetheless the ingredient is, Alexei may maybe well additionally be making it all up… Or is he? Let’s elevate a opinion at the evidence.
Possess you considered Avengers: Endgame?
The first time we hear about these alleged adventures is after we meet up with the faded Red Guardian, who has been imprisoned within the Russian Gulag for years. He’s arm-wrestling fellow inmates one after the other, and beguiling them with tales of stopping Cap. “There he is — Captain The United States,” he says. “Within the wreck, the Red Guardian’s time has attain! I engage encourage of his protect. Head to transfer, it’s a check of power!”
Sounds animated! And but, when one among the inmates asks Alexei what 365 days this confrontation took feature, he replies, “I don’t know. 1984.” Which, as he is then reminded, would point out Captain The United States change into once nonetheless on ice at the time, frozen in suspended animation. So how may maybe well they also maintain fought every different?
As we all realized in history class, Steve Rogers change into once born in 1918 in correct feeble Brooklyn, USA. After years of dreaming of joining the navy so he may maybe well additionally strive against in World Battle II, he underwent Dr. Erskine’s Sizable Soldier experiment as share of Project Rebirth and adopted the Captain The United States mantle. Rogers grew to turn out to be a hero and indirectly went into the ice in 1945 while stopping a bombing attack on the United States initiated by the Red Skull. That’s when Cap entered suspended animation and remained frozen for roughly 66 years before being stumbled on and thawed by S.H.I.E.L.D. brokers in 2011 or 2012.
Captain The United States change into once nonetheless on ice at the time, frozen in suspended animation.
So that can point out that Red Guardian’s legend about stopping Cap in 1984 doesn’t accomplish a ton of sense, proper? Nonetheless presumably Alexei horny bought the dates scandalous and truly he change into once talking about one thing that occurred assist within the ’40s…? Well, striking apart the truth that the prologue of Dim Widow gorgeous grand establishes that Alexei change into once a younger man within the 1990s than he is within the extra or much less up-to-the-minute timeframe that most of the film is determined all the strategy via 2016 — which would per chance maybe well seem to point to that he ages on the total esteem the remainder of us — there’s additionally the truth that the U.S. and Russia were allies all the strategy via World Battle II. So why would they be stopping? Also, the Guardian mentions “having the nuclear codes” all the strategy via his strive against with Cap, which again, doesn’t line up with a 1940s match-up.
It’s seemingly, perceive that, that Red Guardian truly fought a obvious version of Cap, as we now know that the U.S. government persisted to experiment on its win troopers, including many African-American males, now not lower than into the 1950s. These experiments resulted in Isaiah Bradley, who we met in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, turning into an impressive soldier in his win proper. Wonder has left it unclear at this point whether or now not or now not Bradley truly donned a Captain American uniform as he did within the comics, on the different hand it’s now not out of the search files from that he or some different American soldier did in 1984.
Red Guardian’s Connection to Dim Widow (and Captain The United States)
Nonetheless on the different hand, at one point in Dim Widow Alexei asks Natasha if Cap ever talked about him to her. He even says that he feels esteem they’re extra “contemporaries” than enemies — so, you know, guys from the identical period. And since Steve Rogers’ identification is publicly known, presumably Alexei may maybe well presumably be conscious that his “up-to-the-minute” is esteem 100 years feeble. Doesn’t truly add up…
Of path, what’s truly occurring with Red Guardian is that here is all a funny small throughline for David Harbour’s persona, and it additionally contrasts your total idea of the sparkling, upstanding, supreme Captain The United States — symbol of the correct feeble U.S. of A. — with the fallen relic of the previous that change into once the Soviet Union, which perceive that Red Guardian symbolized.
Nonetheless on the different hand (again)…
Steve Rogers did lope via time in Avengers: Endgame when he change into once on a mission to achieve assist your complete Infinity Stones to their rightful locations in time/home. We now haven’t any idea what he did all the strategy via that length or even how long he change into once long previous for, so he truly may maybe well additionally’ve fought Red Guardian in what would’ve been Alexei’s previous nevertheless Steve’s direct!
You know what? I truly hope that’s the acknowledge here, if completely for Alexei’s sake.
For extra on the film, verify out our Dim Widow put up credit scene and ending defined, dig in on the history of Julia Louis-Dreyfus’ Contessa Valentina Allegra de Fontaine, or ranking an rationalization of Taskmaster’s correct identification within the film. That it’s seemingly you’ll additionally read our analysis of Dim Widow here!