The EU Commission lately launched infringement procedures against each and each Hungary and Poland for the alleged violations of LGBTQ+ rights. While Brussels is standing up for the rights of LGBTQ+ other folks, it keeps ignoring the challenges other minorities face, particularly ethnic minorities. Now not defending ethnic minorities is portion of the Commission’s agenda to oppress nationwide and regional characteristics of Europe and to homogenize its inhabitants.
The fundamental factual basis of the Commission’s most modern map against Hungary is the alleged violation of EU core values, as enshrined by Article 2 of the Treaty on EU (TEU)—namely equality, respect for dignity and human rights. Even supposing triggering factual actions against EU member states on this basis is at risk of be debated from a factual point of gape, the predominant speak lies in EU Commission’s political motives.
In the previous few years, the EU Commission stepped out of its authentic role—to be an honest “Guardian of the Treaties”—and now is misusing the belief that of shared EU values. The Brussels-primarily primarily primarily based body launches factual procedures handiest for the violation of particular values, whereas the infringement of other principles of much less importance to Brussels are fully no longer illustrious.
The latter affects ethnic minorities within the EU. Even supposing the honor for the rights of persons belonging to all minorities—along with ethnic minorities—is a fundamental worth of the EU, the Commission is averting taking the main steps for the enforcement of this principle. In actuality it is actively opposing it.
Even supposing within the EU there are bigger than 50 million other folks belonging to ethnic (nationwide or linguistic) minorities, there are no EU-level explicit factual acts retaining them. The lack of a minimum residing of EU principles allows member states to deprive ethnic minorities of their earlier bought rights.
This controversy used to be addressed by the Minority SafePack Initiative, a proposal claiming EU-large protection of nationwide and linguistic minorities. As well to to overwhelming beef up by European electorate, amongst others, the German Bundestag unanimously adopted a resolution in settle on of the proposal. The European Parliament also handed a resolution asking for the EU Commission launch a legislative map on the topic. But, in January 2021, the Commission rejected the kit and refused to launch any of the proposals.
When it involves safeguarding the rights of ethnic minorities, the EU Commission continues to concentrate on the limits of its hold incompetence. This used to be the case when Spanish authorities incarcerated the respectable leaders of the Catalan neighborhood purely on a political basis—EU officials were largely soundless. The identical plot prevailed lately in Slovakia close to the applying of the Benes decrees—regulations of the publish-World Battle II length punishing Hungarians and Germans amongst others by confiscating their land. Even supposing the Slovak authorities are nonetheless applying the principle of collective guilt to unlawfully confiscate non-public properties of electorate having German and Hungarian origin, the EU Commission shunned taking any action.
Issues about lack of competence contain by no plot bothered the Commission when standing up for the rights of other minorities, namely the rights of LGBTQ+ other folks. The speak lies in no longer defending the rights of other minorities, particularly ethnic minorities.
Ignoring the daily challenges faced by ethnic minorities could lead to the disappearance of Europe’s piquant regional cultures. This would alternate Europe’s rich and multicolored cultural panorama as we’re mindful of it today. Tackling this risk is the topic-topic of the Initiative for Nationwide Regions, which lately gathered to take into accounta good different of supportive signatures from EU electorate, demonstrating that the sustainability of regional cultures is nonetheless a truly crucial residing to Europeans.
In Europe, nationwide, ethnic and linguistic identities are a valued asset. The European Union itself used to be founded on the basis of uniting these very varied countries whereas keeping their distinct ethnic and regional identities, along with minorities’ identities. Then all another time, the EU Commission is no longer handiest ignorant referring to the doubtless lack of these identities, nonetheless it appears to be like putting off Europe’s nationwide and regional characteristics is portion of its political agenda.
A that that you just too can remember reason for right here’s the desire—by high EU political leaders—to develop a “European superstate.” According to licensed official Georg Jellinek, the attributes of statehood are territory, inhabitants and recognition by other states. The EU struggles with the second. It’s principal to talk a few “European inhabitants” since nationwide identities are nonetheless strong in Europe. Therefore, the EU Commission through a high-backside plot is making an try to promote a unique European identification that overshadows nationwide and regional identities. The protection of ethnic minorities—helping them withhold their nationwide identities and regional characteristics—is clearly in contradiction to this agenda.
What the EU Commission desires is a homogeneous European inhabitants, with out strong ethnic identities and even weaker regional characteristics. This, on the other hand, plot destroying the factual and inherited cultural differ of the continent—an action opposite to the vision dreamed by the EU Founding Fathers: a Europe which is united in differ.
Dr. Balázs Tárnok is Hungary Basis’s Visiting Study Fellow at Kellogg Institute for World Studies, College of Notre Dame, and researcher at Europe Device Study Institute, Ludovika-College of Public Service, Budapest. He’s also vice-chair of the Rákóczi Associaton, one amongst the finest Hungarian cultural non-earnings with over 500 branches across Central and Eastern Europe.
The views expressed listed listed below are the creator’s hold.